Not easy to use. Smidges are hard to remove. Transfers to lower lids too much Not easy to use. Smidges are hard to remove. Transfers to lower lids too much

Wanted to love: I tried this for weeks hoping I would eventually love it. The one good thing about this eye liner is that it doesn’t smear even with watery eyes! However, the cons unfortunately outnumber this great feature. First,... Wanted to love: I tried this for weeks hoping I would eventually love it. The one good thing about this eye liner is that it doesn’t smear even with watery eyes! However, the cons unfortunately outnumber this great feature. First, it is extremely difficult to apply. I’ve tried many liquid eyeliners and this one by far is the most difficult to apply. I blame it on the applicator mostly because it is not a pointed tip. You will never be able to get a fine consistent line or cat eye with it. Secondly, if you get any of the liner on your lashes it will cause them to clump together. Lastly, even with using an eye makeup remover it does not come off easily. I think if some changes were made to the applicator I may be willing to retry but for now I’m in search of a different option.

Best liquid eyeline ever: This is the only liquid eyeliner that doesn't come off until you are ready to remove it. This is the only one I would ever use since all the other I've tried eventually wear off on... Best liquid eyeline ever: This is the only liquid eyeliner that doesn't come off until you are ready to remove it. This is the only one I would ever use since all the other I've tried eventually wear off on their own.

Difficult application: Eyeliner tip is not a brush..tip is very hard. Is NOT easy to use. Very difficult...It streaks when applied. Have to go over several times to get a solid line .then have to even it out and touch... Difficult application: Eyeliner tip is not a brush..tip is very hard. Is NOT easy to use. Very difficult...It streaks when applied. Have to go over several times to get a solid line .then have to even it out and touch up with a damp qtip..the wand is huge compared to the base that holds the product ...product does stay on and long lasting however.

Easy to use eyeliner: It goes on evenly and stays on well. It definitely feels very light and not heavy on my eyes. Easy to use eyeliner: It goes on evenly and stays on well. It definitely feels very light and not heavy on my eyes.

Not easy to use. Smidges are hard to remove. Transfers to lower lids too much Not easy to use. Smidges are hard to remove. Transfers to lower lids too much

Wanted to love: I tried this for weeks hoping I would eventually love it. The one good thing about this eye liner is that it doesn’t smear even with watery eyes! However, the cons unfortunately outnumber this great feature. First,... Wanted to love: I tried this for weeks hoping I would eventually love it. The one good thing about this eye liner is that it doesn’t smear even with watery eyes! However, the cons unfortunately outnumber this great feature. First, it is extremely difficult to apply. I’ve tried many liquid eyeliners and this one by far is the most difficult to apply. I blame it on the applicator mostly because it is not a pointed tip. You will never be able to get a fine consistent line or cat eye with it. Secondly, if you get any of the liner on your lashes it will cause them to clump together. Lastly, even with using an eye makeup remover it does not come off easily. I think if some changes were made to the applicator I may be willing to retry but for now I’m in search of a different option.

Best liquid eyeline ever: This is the only liquid eyeliner that doesn't come off until you are ready to remove it. This is the only one I would ever use since all the other I've tried eventually wear off on... Best liquid eyeline ever: This is the only liquid eyeliner that doesn't come off until you are ready to remove it. This is the only one I would ever use since all the other I've tried eventually wear off on their own.

Difficult application: Eyeliner tip is not a brush..tip is very hard. Is NOT easy to use. Very difficult...It streaks when applied. Have to go over several times to get a solid line .then have to even it out and touch... Difficult application: Eyeliner tip is not a brush..tip is very hard. Is NOT easy to use. Very difficult...It streaks when applied. Have to go over several times to get a solid line .then have to even it out and touch up with a damp qtip..the wand is huge compared to the base that holds the product ...product does stay on and long lasting however.

Easy to use eyeliner: It goes on evenly and stays on well. It definitely feels very light and not heavy on my eyes. Easy to use eyeliner: It goes on evenly and stays on well. It definitely feels very light and not heavy on my eyes.